What Can I Use in Instead of Butter Flavored Shortening?

Have you ever baked a dish that called for butter-flavored shortening but ran out? You do not need to be concerned. We’re ready to assist you with effective replacements!

Butter is the greatest and most apparent option for butter-flavored shortening. Most recipes that call for shortening may be made with butter and taste just the same. There are other options, but they will not be butter-flavored. That is why we will concentrate on using butter instead of shortening.

Continue reading to see how butter varies from shortening and about the other options!

The Best Substitute for Butter-Flavored Shortening: Butter!

The first shortening substitute that should spring to mind is butter. It not only has the same flavor, but it also has superb consistency and texture. Some individuals say it leaves a nicer impression than shortening, although this depends on the sort of baked items.

When it comes to cookies, for example, butter is the finest substitute for shortening since it contains the proper balance of fat and water. During baking, the water content turns to steam, which results in the formation of gluten. As a result, the cookies acquire their characteristic crunchy texture.

Another advantage of using butter as a shortening replacement is its low melting point. Your baked products expand and puff up when the fat in them melts. Because of the lower melting point of butter, this occurs quicker than shortening.

Also, since butter is creamier than shortening, it is an excellent replacement for baked items that need a light, airy texture.

How to Use Butter Instead of Butter-Flavored Shortening?

When it comes to recipes, whether you’re cooking or baking, you want to acquire the correct proportions to prevent any mishaps. Let’s face it, we’ve all attempted baking and failed miserably at some time.

When using butter instead of shortening, you must do certain calculations in order to get the necessary quantities. If your recipe calls for half a cup of shortening, increase the quantity by 1.25. This should yield roughly 4 oz.

See also  13 Best Substitute For Pepperoncini Peppers in Mississippi Pot Roast

Then, multiply the butter weight by 0.15 to get about 0.5 ounces. Eliminate this quantity from the recipe, and you’ll be OK.

Since shortening and butter have differing water and fat contents, you must do these calculations. As a result, utilizing the same quantity will result in an incorrect result.

The Best Shortening Substitutes for Baking That Aren’t Butter

There’s a good possibility you don’t have butter in your fridge either. That is why we will inform you about some other alternatives to shortening. If you’re searching for a substitute for butter-flavored shortening, keep in mind that they won’t taste like butter.


Lard is just reduced swine fat, making it an ideal substitute for shortening. It has a high smoke point and a high amount of monounsaturated fats. Also, since it contains little water, it produces little steam.

Because of its properties, lard may be used for deep frying. You should merely be aware that most packaged lard is hydrogenated, which means it contains a lot of trans fats. Thus, be sure you’re obtaining pure lard from a reputable supplier.

Coconut Oil

Coconut oil is well recognized for its many applications. It may be used in hair care, skincare, and, of course, cookery. Because of its high fat content, coconut oil might be used in place of shortening if you ran out.

Moreover, it has a pleasant flavor that lends a savory note to the finished product. Yet, some individuals avoid using it for that same reason. Apparently, not everyone can assure the flavor of coconut in biscuits!

It may be used in the same quantities as shortening.

Bacon Fat

Bacon fat is related to lard, and it is regarded a variety or form of it. You may use it in recipes that call for a lot of fat.

Nonetheless, there is a good likelihood that the flavor of bacon fat will be present in the finished result. It may not appear in cooking, but it will undoubtedly emerge in baked products. This is particularly true since bacon fat is saltier than other alternatives, such as coconut oil.

See also  15 Substitute For Queso Fresco Cheese You Never Know Existed

Hence, while using bacon fat for your dish, be sure the flavor is to your liking. Nobody wants to eat bacon biscuits!


If the recipe calls for vegetable shortening, you may substitute margarine, a popular butter alternative. You may use it in the same quantities as you would shortening.

There is one thing you should know about margarine: it is extensively processed. As a result, it lacks the flavor of butter. You may find it strange at first, but you’ll grow accustomed to it quickly.

Nevertheless, it is not advisable to consume it in large quantities since it lacks the nutritious benefits of butter.

Other Substitutes of Shortening for Different Purposes

If you don’t mind the differing tastes, there are several additional shortening replacements you may use in baking or cooking. These are all of the substitutions for every kind of cooking you undertake.


Shortening is often included in cookie recipes because it produces a crumbly texture. Moreover, the cookies do not spread much, resulting in a dome-like shape.

You may get the same results by combining butter and coconut oil. The oil will slow down the butter’s impact, giving you a final finish akin to shortening.

However, using just butter will result in flatter and crispier cookies, which some people dislike. But, if you are low on coconut oil, you may still use it.


While preparing biscuits, most people strive for a flaky texture. Unlike cookies, tall baked items must be fluffy, sifted, and maybe a little chewy. Shortening is used in biscuits because it ensures the appropriate flakiness. Other folks, however, prefer to use butter since it has a nicer taste.

That is why, at least for preparing biscuits, butter is one of the greatest alternatives to shortening. But, you may also substitute coconut oil. You may also use almond flour instead of all-purpose flour.


Bread dough must have enough fat to offer the softness that bread is famous for. Chefs use butter to create brioche and oil to cook challah for this reason. Together with the other components, each form of bread requires its specific quantity of fat.

See also  The Most Flavorsome Chili Oil Substitute List: We Gathered 14

If your bread recipe calls for shortening, substitute oil, butter, or leaf lard. Any of the solutions discussed above will achieve the desired softness while also making the bread airy and soft enough for savoriness.


The frosting is a little difficult to create since it contains more than simply flour and butter. Although replacing shortening in cookies and biscuits is simple, the same cannot be said for frosting. The best option is to combine butter, margarine, and coconut oil.

Final Thoughts

As you can see, there are a variety of alternatives to shortening. Don’t worry if you run out before finishing your recipe. Simply check in your fridge for some cooking oil or butter, and you’ll be good!


Can you substitute butter for butter flavored shortening?

Yes, butter and shortening may be used interchangeably in baked items and as a one-to-one substitute.

What is a substitute for Crisco butter shortening?

Butter is a natural shortening alternative since it has a comparable texture and a more savory taste. Here’s how to substitute butter for shortening in a recipe that asks for it: 1 cup Plus 2 tablespoons butter equals 1 cup shortening.

What is butter flavor shortening?

Crisco Butter Flavor Shortening has the same properties as Crisco All-Vegetable Shortening, but it adds a delicious buttery taste to meals. Crisco Shortening is now available in easy-to-measure sticks in both original and butter flavors for your convenience.

Is butter flavored shortening same as margarine?

We’re sure you’re asking, “Is margarine shortening since it’s manufactured with vegetable oil?” They are similar, but not identical. The difference between margarine and shortening is that shortening is entirely composed of fat and includes no water.

Does butter flavored Crisco taste like butter?

Butter “flavored” stuff, in my opinion, tastes nothing like actual butter. In recipes, there is no replacement for genuine butter. For the fat, I use half butter and half standard Crisco shortening in my pie crusts. The butter adds flavor to the crusts, while the shortening makes them flaky.

What is a substitute for butter flavor?

Vanilla extract takes roughly two months to develop, but because of its taste and recognizability in practically every baking recipe, vanilla extract is an excellent alternative for butter extract. It’s a must-have for any serious chef.

Is it better to use Crisco or butter for chocolate chip cookies?

While butter adds taste, utilizing just butter results in flat, spreadable cookies. Shortening gives structure but does not contribute taste. You get the best of both worlds when you combine them. Use genuine butter whenever possible.

How much butter do I use instead of 1 2 cup shortening?

2 cup shortening (95.5 grams), although you may use butter. Divide the weight of the shortening by 1.25 to get 114.6 grams. This is the amount of butter you’ll need. Using Butter Instead of Shortening

Assume you have a cake recipe that calls for 1 cup of sugar.

What is best substitute for shortening?

Vegetable oil, coconut oil, peanut oil, avocado oil, and grapeseed oil all have high smoke points and may be used for frying, but vegetable oil is your best choice since it’s cheap and flavorless.

Rate this post