We Compiled a List of 20+ Pimento Substitutes

Without the addition of peppers, spices, or other flavors, most of our favorite foods would not taste as wonderful or be as complete. That is why, if we run out of pimento when cooking, we should be aware of alternative substitutions.

In most regions of the globe, fresh pimentos are difficult to come by. Cans or jars of pimento or other sweet peppers may be utilized. However, if you are unable to locate one, there are a few options to consider.

  1. Red bell peppers
  2. Red pepper flakes
  3. Peppadew peppers
  4. Cinnamon
  5. Cherry peppers
  6. Ground Cloves
  7. Piquillo Pepper

Before we get into the large number of alternatives, let’s learn more about this pepper.

22 Best Substitute For Pimento 

Pimento is a pepper that may be used in a number of recipes. Pimentos, sometimes known as pimientos by others, is the Spanish term for pepper. It tastes sweet with a tinge of spice. It is often red and huge, measuring 2-3 inches broad and 3-4 inches long with a short, thick stem.

Pimento is available fresh, ground (also called as paprika), in jarred or canned forms, and in striped, sliced, or diced forms. This is often used in sauces and dips, but it’s also great for stuffing, pickling, and daily cooking.

Two popular pimento dishes are pimento cheese and pickled pimento peppers. Fresh pimentos are difficult to come by in most regions of the globe.

Instead of giving up on your cooking because you can’t locate pimentos, consider one of these common substitutes:

Red Bell Peppers

The red bell pepper looks to be the finest alternative for pimento. They’re both sweet but not extremely spicy, and red bell peppers are widely available at markets and grocery shops.

2–3 teaspoons chopped red bell peppers may be used in place of the 2 tablespoons pimentos.

Red pepper flakes

Red pepper flakes are just crushed red peppers that work well in place of pimentos. This is a mixture of peppers, the bulk of which are cayenne peppers, that gives a multidimensional taste and spice to any meal.

This is a globally popular spice that combines well with every pasta meal and, of course, pizza. To taste, adjust the amount of red pepper flakes.



Cinnamon, due to its strong taste and scent, may also be used in lieu of ground pimento. However, to prevent dominating the meal, use this in combination with nutmeg or cloves.

See also  12 Best Guajillo Chiles Substitute To Impress Your Mexican GF

Peppadew peppers

This variety of pepper, which is readily accessible in South Africa, gives both sweet and spicy taste to any food without overpowering it.

This may be used to flavor baked goods, stuffing, and fresh salads. This may also be served raw or as part of a martini.

In a 1:1 ratio, use the same quantity of pimento.

Cherry peppers


Cherry peppers, which look like little bombs, may add extra spice to your meal but are considerably hotter than pimento. It is often used as stuffing and is inexpensive, particularly in jars.

Remember that using the same quantity of pimento (1:1) will result in a considerably hotter meal than you planned.

Ground Cloves

Because of their strong taste, ground cloves may be used in place of pimento powder in most recipes. Ground cloves are useful in a variety of dishes, including stews, curries, and beverages.

Piquillo Pepper


Piquillo peppers may also be used in place of pimentos. It doesn’t have much heat, is sweet but has a more nuanced taste, and is rather huge. It is very easy to cultivate at home. This is the greatest alternative for pimento in roasting, pickling, and frying.

Holland Sweet Peppers

Holland sweet peppers are also known as Dutch chilies. This is available in red, yellow, orange, brown, and white. It has a moderate spicy taste and a huge size, making it ideal for grilling, stuffing, and roasting.

Use the same quantity of Holland sweet peppers as you would pimentos.

Cubanelle Peppers

Cubanelle peppers are sweet and fragrant, with a lower heat than other peppers. They are bigger and more tasty than pimentos and come in orange, green, or red.

Because they grow more aromatic when cooked, this is also known as frying peppers. It makes a tasty complement to any salad and is big enough to fill.

Italian Sweet Peppers

Because Italian sweet peppers are often sweet and not spicy, they make an ideal substitution for pimentos. One of its variations is corno di toro. It is perfect for grilling, roasting, stuffing, and a variety of other purposes because to its meaty and sweet flavor.

Star Anise


Star anise, like pimentos, has a strong taste that may be utilized in stews, curries, and marinades.

When using star anise, no other spices are required since it is delicious enough on its own.

Pumpkin Pie Spice

Pumpkin pie spice not only compliments sweets but also acts as a wonderful alternative for pimento because to the savory taste obtained from the mixture of cloves, ginger, nutmeg, cinnamon, and allspice. It’s basically a combination of those.

See also  7 Dark Corn Syrup Substitute For Cooking And Baking

This is a frequent ingredient in baked products and soups. Remember that this might be overwhelming, so put just a tiny quantity on your food.

Apple Pie Spice


Another potential replacement is apple pie spice. It is a spice combination of cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, allspice, and sometimes cardamom that is perfect for baking delicacies.

Add little quantities of apple spice to your food until it has the appropriate taste.

Corno Di Toro Peppers

Corno Di Toro is a sort of Italian sweet pepper, as previously described. This pepper is also known as the horn of the bull because to its longhorn form, which may reach up to 8 inches in length.

This is often sweeter and less spicy than pimentos.This may be orange, yellow, or red and is excellent for grilling, roasting, sautéing, frying, and eating raw.

Corno di toro is also abundant in antioxidants, vitamins A and C, and other nutrients that provide a variety of health advantages.

Ground Cayenne Peppers


Cayenne peppers are usually recognized as the medical plant’s king. This is a great addition to any recipe since it offers a moderate degree of spice and works well as a replacement for pimentos, especially in soups and sauces.

It is related to and belongs to the same family as bell peppers and jalapenos.

1 teaspoon of cayenne pepper may be substituted for 1 teaspoon ground pimento.

Ancho Chili Powder

Ancho chili powder, prepared from dried poblano peppers, gives a fiery kick to a wide range of meals, most notably Mexican soups, salads, and marinades. Chili powder, on the other hand, is merely dried poblano pepper. The former is a spice mixture.

Although it is somewhat hotter than pimentos, it is an excellent replacement since it adds an authentic Mexican flavor to any meal. Begin with little quantities and progressively increase until the desired taste is achieved.

Black Ground Peppers


Black ground peppers are the most basic and generally accessible alternative and are used all around the globe. You can simulate the spice and taste of pimentos with a modest bit of pepper.

Begin with a little bit of black pepper and gradually increase it until you obtain the desired taste.

Five Spice Powder

Five-spice powders originated in China. It is a spice combination that, due to its savory taste, may be used in place of pimentos. This is widely available in a number of retailers and adds tastes to your food that will make it more oriental.

See also  How To Reheat Your Pulled Pork? 5 Easy Methods That Can Be Done At Home

Banana Peppers


Banana peppers are chili peppers that may substitute for pimentos. It has a strong scent that is comparable to pimentos but somewhat sweeter.

It is a medium-sized, long, predominantly yellow pepper, thus the name.

This may be filled and pickled as well as eaten raw.

Mace(Ground Nutmeg)

One of the most versatile spices is mace, often known as ground nutmeg. It has a similar taste and scent like pimentos. Combine nutmeg or mace with ground cloves for a more delicious replacement.

Canned Pimento


If fresh pimentos are unavailable, this is the most apparent option. This is available in sliced, diced, or chopped form at markets and grocery shops, making it considerably simpler to use in cooking.

Because of the salt marinade, canned pimento is low in fat and calories but heavy in sodium.

Mixed Spice

Mixed spice is a combination of allspice, cinnamon, and nutmeg that imparts a moderate spicy taste to your meal while also complementing the sweetness of pimentos. This may easily be used for any meal.

Pimento Substitute Related FAQs

What spice has the most in common with pimentos?

Pimento-like peppers include red bell peppers, peppadews, cherry peppers, piquillo peppers, Corno di toro peppers, banana peppers, and cubanelle peppers.

These peppers have the same sweetness and, in some ways, the same amount of spice as pimentos.

Is Pimento the same as Red Bell Pepper?

Pimento, on the other hand, has a sweeter and more fragrant taste than red bell pepper.

Is the level of heat the same in different types of peppers?

No, various varieties of peppers have differing degrees of heat, so select a substitution that is mild enough for your taste buds.

How should pimentos be stored?

Once opened, the jarred pimentos should be stored in the refrigerator for up to nine months.

If you can locate fresh pimentos in your local grocery store or market, put them in the fridge to preserve their crispness for up to a week.


4-easy-ways-to-cook-with-red-bell-peppersarticleswww.masterclass.comTypes, Taste, and an Easy Stuffed Bell Peppers Recipe. obtained from https:

about-black-peppermccormickarticleswww.mccormick.comBlack pepper uses, pairings, and recipes. obtained from https:


What can you substitute for pimento?

Bell peppers are generally the simplest to locate as a replacement for fresh pimentos, but any sweeter red pepper species, such as the piquillo pepper, corno di toro pepper, or any Italian sweet pepper, would suffice.

Are pimento and red pepper the same?

All roasted red peppers are not pimentos. Pimentos are offered in little jars, while roasted red peppers are often sold in bigger containers. They are also the little amount of red found in olives.

What is pimento the same as?

Allspice, often known as pimento, is valued for its varied and adaptable taste. The modest brown fruit, which tastes like cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove, is vital in Caribbean and Middle Eastern cookery, as well as popular in many European-style meals.

What is pimento called in the US?

Allspice (Pimenta dioica), often known as Jamaican pepper or pimento, is a tropical evergreen tree in the Myrtaceae family and the source of a very scented spice.

What is pimento in Caribbean?

In Jamaica, pimento seed refers to the dried unripe fruit of the Pimenta dioica tree, a natural evergreen shrub present in all 14 parishes. It is also known as allspice, pimenta, Jamaica pepper, or myrtle pepper and is native to the Caribbean and Central America.

Are there different types of pimentos?

Pimientos are a broad category that includes many different varieties of peppers. The ‘Lipstick’ cultivar has vivid red pods that are 3-4 inches long. Another kind is the squat ‘Red Ruffled Pimiento’ pepper, which has a pumpkin-like form.

Why is it called pimento?

Name. Both Spanish pimiento and Portuguese pimento are derived from the Latin pigmentum (“pigment; coloring”) and were originally applied to bell peppers. The English borrowed the loanwords “pimiento” and “pimento” for what is known in Spanish as pimentón and in Portuguese as pimento.

What is the difference between pimento and pimiento?

thus here’s what we know thus far: Pimientos are sweet cherry peppers that rate low and mild on the Scoville heat index meter. Pimiento is a Spanish term that developed into pimento through time. The term’s derivation really translates to bell pepper.

Which spice is pimento?

Pimento, often known as Jamaican pepper, is indigenous to the West Indies and South America (though Jamaica produces the majority of the world’s supply). It’s also known as allspice since it tastes like cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves.

Rate this post