The Ultimate Cremini Mushroom Substitutes: We have twenty

Cremini mushrooms are distinguished by their more mushroom-like scent and flavor when compared to other mushroom kinds such as the button mushroom. Cremini mushrooms are also quite versatile. You may demonstrate it by demonstrating its ability to complement a variety of recipes and foods.

Rice, spaghetti, any form of meat, salad, and potatoes are examples of these. It may also be used to produce excellent sauces. If your recipe calls for dried cremini, you may use it instead. Risottos, casseroles, pastas, soups, quesadillas, omelets, salads, bruschetta, tarts, and tacos all benefit from it.

In any event, if you run out, you may select from any of its excellent counterparts, which include:

  1. Button Mushroom
  2. Oyster Mushroom
  3. Shiitake
  4. Portobello
  5. Porcini
  6. Chestnut mushroom
  7. Morel mushroom
  8. Cauliflower
  9. Eggplant

Given the variety of mushrooms available, let’s take a look at why the cremini mushroom is so popular and what its health advantages are.

2o Best Substitute For Cremini Mushroom

Cremini mushrooms are tiny to medium-sized brown mushrooms that are classified alongside portobello and white mushrooms. Cremini, like portobello and white button mushrooms, is widely available. It is readily found in the produce sections of any shop.

Cremini, on the other hand, is immediately distinguished by its characteristic meaty texture and mild and earthy taste. Cremini mushrooms are also more flavorful than white mushrooms.

Cremini mushroom is not only tasty, but it is also healthy for your health. It is nutritious and healthful since it contains a variety of vitamins, nutrients, and minerals. B vitamins, manganese, potassium, folic acid, zinc, phosphorus, selenium, Vitamin D, copper, and manganese are among them. [Source]

If you like using cremini but don’t have any on hand, try the following alternatives:

Button Mushrooms


The button mushroom is perhaps the closest of the various cremini mushroom replacements you will learn today. It’s a fantastic substitute for cremini since it has the same woodsy and mild nutty taste.

Both seem to have a velvety texture and an earthy fragrance. It is an excellent replacement since it is accessible all year, boosting convenience. You’ll adore it in your veggie stew and in any potato dish. It works nicely for cooking baked, mashed, or fried potatoes.

It’s a versatile mushroom kind that goes well with vegetable stew, fowl, pork, pasta, and rice. You may also use it in salads, sauces, pizza, and burgers.

The preparation of button mushrooms is likewise quite similar to that of cremini mushrooms. It may be fried, marinated, dried, pickled, boiled, or grilled.

It is inexpensive and widely accessible. This means it’s the closest and most convenient substitute for cremini whether making a mushroom sauce, salad, or soup. It also goes well with burgers, spaghetti, and pizza.

Oyster Mushroom

The oyster mushroom is the second cremini mushroom alternative we’ll discuss. Because of its taste, texture, and color, it is an excellent substitute for cremini. However, it is not as flavorful or meaty as other cremini replacements.

Regardless, it may make your food more flavorful and fascinating. Oyster mushrooms are typically white in hue. There is also a brown variation that looks remarkably identical to cremini.

Another factor that makes oyster mushroom an excellent substitute is its pleasant texture and taste. This exact flavor and texture will not significantly alter the taste of your dishes.

See also  7 Best Zaatar Substitute For Your Delicious Middle East Recipe

Shiitake Mushroom


The shiitake mushroom, often known by various names such as black forest and oak, is an excellent replacement for cremini. It is light brown and readily identified due to its spongy and mushy character. It has the size and form of a cremini.

One interesting aspect about shiitake is that it has an earthy taste. It also has a more mild taste profile than cremini. It has a delicate bloom that makes it an even better option for cremini, particularly for making stews, pasta, barbecues, stir-fries, and barbecues.

This mushroom may also be used to thicken sauces. However, since it is rather chewy, use caution when substituting this mushroom for cremini. To increase the flavor, add fresh ones as well.

Portobello Mushroom

Portobello has an earthy, silky taste that is similar to cremini. Portobello, with its umami flavor, may also be used as a meat substitute, similar to cremini.

Quick Note

Because portobello mushrooms contain a lot of water, they might become deformed when cooked.

Despite this, you can be certain that their tastes will remain intact. There are several ways to prepare portobello, including roasting and grilling. It also goes well with pizza, sauces, soups, and pasta.

Porcini Mushroom


If you’re seeking for a cremini replacement with a rich taste and subtle aroma, try porcini mushrooms. This mushroom has the same nutritional value as cremini.

The porous texture of this mushroom, however, distinguishes it from the others. This particular texture is responsible for its water-absorbent properties.

If you want to use it in cooking, rinse it first and then dry it with paper towels. The reason for this is because the mushroom may exude water when cooking the meal. It may also be stewed, boiled, or sautéed. Roasting the porcini mushroom also brings forth its greatest taste.

Chestnut Mushroom

The chestnut mushroom is also known as the brown mushroom because to its brownish tan appearance. In most circumstances, it grows in clusters and is considered the mature variety of the white mushroom.

Chestnut mushrooms are similar in size, flavor, and taste to cremini, making them an excellent cremini substitute. It is safe to use in lieu of cremini in any meals that call for it, including as sauces and soups, as well as grilling and roasting.

Morel Mushroom


Using morel mushrooms in your dishes will undoubtedly make them more intriguing to the taste senses, thanks to their characteristic umami and buttery flavor. Morel mushrooms have a silky feel that you will notice.

Use it in any dish that calls for baking or frying. It is also a fantastic substitute for cremini for making stews, salads, pies, and risottos. However, avoid over-seasoning this item to prevent losing its delicate but pleasant scent.


If you’re looking for a non-mushroom alternative to cremini, cauliflower is a good choice. This delectable but affordable replacement is a fantastic option since it is readily accessible year round.

See also  17 Best Pearl Onions Substitute For Your Favorite Soup Recipe

Cauliflower is creamy and rich in texture, so it goes well with meat dishes, vegetables, cream, rice, pasta, and fish. Cauliflower’s buttery flavor and crisp texture make it an excellent substitute for cremini mushrooms. This is particularly true if you use butter, spices, or cream to prepare it.

However, as a non-mushroom replacement, cauliflower cannot be expected to have its woodsy and earthy flavor. Regardless, it may considerably enhance the flavor of your food.


Because of its meaty and soft texture, eggplant may provide additional flavor to any meal that calls for cremini. It may also make your foods bitter.

It is a flexible replacement that may be used in a variety of ways, including baking, frying, boiling, and grilling.

It also goes well with meats like tender beef and pig. You may also use it in vegetable stews. When cooked, eggplant will resemble other mushrooms, such as cremini, in that it will become delicate, soft, and velvety.


Chickpeas have a gritty, creamy texture and a nutty flavor, making them excellent cremini alternatives. It is also high in protein, which is beneficial since it may substitute meat while keeping the fat level of your recipe low.

You’ll also like utilizing this item, particularly if you enjoy cooking vegetarian recipes.


If you’re looking for a non-mushroom replacement for cremini, zucchini is a good option. The wonderful thing about zucchini is that when cooked, it has a sweet, delicious, and mild taste, as well as a soft texture.

You can cook with zucchini in a variety of ways. It may be grilled, fried, baked, roasted, pickled, or stewed. Zucchini’s subtle earthy scent and silky texture are similar to cremini.

However, in terms of bitterness, it is quite similar to eggplants. It is also highly suggested to sprinkle zucchini with salt before cooking to remove any extra water.


Tofu has a distinct flavor than cremini. The textures of the two are also distinct. When tofu is combined with soy sauce, it retains its earthy and nutty taste, making it a wonderful alternative for cremini.

In case there is no soy sauce, marinade the tofu in either chicken or veggie stock. This is done to enhance the flavor of this substance. To make it seem like cremini, sprinkle it with lemon juice.

Sun-dried Tomato


Sun-dried tomatoes’ savory and sweet flavors, paired with their soft and chewy textures, making them an excellent alternative for cremini. It may be used in vegetable stews, soups, risotto, sauces, and pasta.

Another reason we prefer this cremini replacement is that it complements spices and herbs wonderfully. It is a tasty complement to salads and may give your foods a very sweet and acidic flavor.

Sun-dried tomatoes’ ability to combine with practically all vegetables, cereals, and pasta demonstrates their versatility.

Russet Potatoes

Russet potatoes are also excellent substitutes for cremini mushrooms. This potato is readily identified by its lengthy stature and stiff, thick skin. Its skin is difficult to peel because to its hardness.

See also  7 Things You Can Use As A Tarragon Substitute When Cooking

The benefit of this potato is that it absorbs liquids effectively. It also goes well with recipes that call for mushrooms. You’ll like using it for frying and baking.

It may not be good for salads and soups, though, since it may result in soggy results.


When cooked, lentils have a deep and delicious taste, as well as a thick and meaty mouthfeel. If you’re making stews or soups, it’s a fantastic substitute for cremini mushrooms.

What’s even wonderful about lentils is their excellent nutritional content. It has a lot of fiber and protein. It should be noted, however, that it lacks the earthy taste of mushrooms.


Onions are excellent complements to any recipe since they provide several health advantages.

Aside from being incredibly healthy, onions may also enhance the taste of your food. White onions, which are sweeter, may be used instead. They go well with meat, soups, and toppings.

Caramelized onions are also wonderful cremini alternatives, particularly when used in steaks and pies. If you want your food to have a fiery flavor, use red onions. It is best to use fresh onions in your dish so that you can savor their powerful tastes.

Yellow Summer Squash

When substituting squash for cremini, use yellow summer squash since other cultivars are exceedingly watery.

The yellow summer squash species has a meaty flavor that makes it an excellent substitute for cremini. Soups, sautéed and baked meals, and side dishes are all examples of this.

While yellow summer squash does not have a mushroom flavor, you may simulate it with little spice. This low-calorie squash is also high in vitamins A and C, as well as protein, iron, and calcium.

Enoki Mushroom

The white, thin, and little enoki mushroom is another suitable cremini mushroom substitute. It tastes somewhat sweet and has a crunchy texture. It is extremely nutritious due to its high fiber and protein content.

Enoki’s petite size and earthy flavor are similar to cremini. You may use it in side dishes and stir-fries that call for cremini mushrooms. They are tasty enough to make your food more fun to consume.

Maitake Mushrooms

Maitake is another mushroom that has the same texture and flavor as cremini. This implies you’ll be able to use it as a substitute while cooking.

What’s amazing about maitake is that it’s not only tasty but also low in fat. It has a greater nutritional content, making it useful for improving immunity.

Shimeji Mushroom

Shimeji is a popular mushroom kind in Japanese cooking. It has the same chewy and crunchy texture as cremini and a meaty and flavorful taste.

Quick Note

The brown shimeji mushroom has a more bitter flavor, so use with caution.

Because shimeji and cremini mushrooms have similar taste characteristics, you may use either one in the absence of the other. It will no longer be mushy after cooked. This makes it suitable for use in a variety of dishes, including as stir-fries, soba, and hot pots.


What are cremini mushroom names?

Cremini mushrooms (also known as cremino, common brown, and Roman) are sometimes sold as “baby bella” or “baby portobello” mushrooms since they are, in fact, juvenile portobello mushrooms. These mushrooms are darker in color and harder than white button mushrooms.

Is Portobello a mature cremini mushroom?

THEY ARE EXACTLY THE SAME KIND OF MUSHROOM. They are all Agaricus bisporus, simply at various stages of development: children are white button mushrooms, teens are brown cremini mushrooms, and adults are brown and considerably bigger versions of their younger selves.

How do you identify a cremini mushroom?

How to Spot Cremini Mushrooms. Cremini mushrooms have dark brown or chestnut colored caps with a whiteish stalk. The cap is shaggier and more textured than that of a button mushroom, but it is still smooth and rounded.

What are mushroom alternatives?

Suggestions for Mushroom Substitutes. Tofu, Eggplant, or Tempeh may be used as Mushroom substitutes since they have a similar flavor and texture. Zucchini and sun-dried tomatoes are two more options.

What is the most expensive mushroom name?

Matsutake mushrooms are the world’s most costly mushrooms, adored by fine-dining establishments in Japan. Because of their dwindling habitat in Japan, the price continues to rise.

What is the name of the little brown mushroom?

Panaeolus foenisecii, often known as the mower’s mushroom, haymaker, or brown hay mushroom, is a common and widely distributed tiny brown fungus found on lawns. It is not edible.

What mushroom is closest to crimini?

White and cremini mushrooms may be used interchangeably, however you will lose some taste if you use white instead of cremini. While substantially more costly, shiitake mushrooms are a viable replacement for creminis.

What is the closest mushroom to cremini?

Portobello mushrooms are the same species as cremini mushrooms, however they mature at a later period. This gives them a more meaty and flavorful taste. In most circumstances, portobello mushrooms will enhance the flavor of your cuisine!

Are baby bella the same as portobello?

Baby Bella Mushrooms Facts

Baby bella mushrooms are similar to Italian portobello (or portabella) mushrooms, although they are a stage younger. Baby bella mushrooms, white button mushrooms, and portobello mushrooms are all maturations of the fungus agaricus bisporus.

What is the rare kind of mushroom?

The fungus, commonly known as the ‘Texas Star,’ is one of the world’s rarest mushrooms and was named the state mushroom of Texas in 2021.

Rate this post