6 Delicious Muenster Cheese Substitutes That Melt In Your Mouth

Muenster cheese has a characteristic nutty, sweet taste that melts in your tongue. Unfortunately, while being a very well-known sort of cheese, it may not be widely accessible at local delis or shops.

What is a suitable alternative for Muenster cheese when none is available? Fortunately, there are six forms of cheese that taste just as good. If you’re strapped for time, here’s a fast rundown:

  • Edam Cheese
  • Gouda
  • Havarti
  • Monterey Jack
  • Port Salut
  • Provolone

Each of these alternatives has the same delectable flavor and silky texture, but they vary in a few subtle ways. Continue reading to learn more about these alternatives!

6 Good Substitutes for Muenster Cheese

Muenster cheese is famed for its nutty, semi-mild taste and is created from pasteurized cow’s milk. This implies that its alternatives should have the same characteristics.

This is why we chose these six cheeses. They all melt with a delightful suppleness and have a similar semi-soft consistency.

The greatest aspect is that they are less expensive than Muenster cheese. As a result, you won’t have any problem locating them in any of your local retailers.

Here’s a breakdown of each sort of cheese and some of its features. We’ll also go through how to utilize each one to make the ideal dinner.

Edam Cheese

Edam is a semi-hard, pale yellow cheese. It is derived from Edam, a tiny Dutch town located to the north of Holland.

It is often marketed in spheres and is distinguished by its mild, somewhat salty taste. This delicious cheese is manufactured using skimmed or semi-skimmed milk from cows. It is one of the healthiest cheeses on our list, owing to its low-fat and high protein content.

Because of its melting characteristics, Edam makes an excellent Muenster cheese alternative. Edam may be used in baked goods, many types of pasta, salads, and sauces. It may also be cubed or thinly sliced and served with a fruit tray or crackers.


Gouda cheese is one of those cheeses that seems to go well with everything. It may be eaten grated, cubed, sliced, or melted. Indeed, Gouda is most renowned for its incredible ability to melt flawlessly, similar to Muenster cheese.

See also  9 Genius Lemon Extract Substitutes For Your Lemon Bars

This mild-flavored Dutch cheese is also made using cow’s milk and has a semi-hard texture. It’s delicious in salads, fondues, and sauces. You can also use it as a creamy topping for macaroni and noodles.

Not only that, but Gouda is an excellent accompaniment to any veggie meal, whether melted or grated. It’s also great for making a delicious grilled cheese sandwich.

One of the distinguishing characteristics of Gouda is that it may be matured between four weeks to a year or even longer. Some kinds of Gouda have been aged for up to five years!

The young cheese has a moderate taste and a semi-soft texture. The more time it is allowed to mature, the denser it grows. The flavor is also improved, yielding a crisper, more flavorful flavor.


Havarti is a well-known Danish variety of cheese. It is produced of cow’s milk and has a semi-soft consistency, comparable to Muenster cheese. Havarti is distinguished by its mild taste, which is somewhat sweet with a nuttiness.

One of Havartis distinguishing characteristics is that it may be found in a variety of tastes due to the addition of herbs and spices. It goes well with bread, crackers, and fruits as a table cheese. To get the most out of the delicate, buttery flavor, slice it very thin.

When Havarti cheese melts, it has a lovely flavor. As a result, you may use it to add flavor and texture to your favorite baked meals.

It takes around three months to age. This contributes to its distinctive semi-soft feel. When kept for a longer period of time, Havarti gets saltier and more nutty in taste.

Monterey Jack

Monterey Jack is a traditional American cheese. It’s light yellow with a buttery, creamy texture and a hard, compact structure.

It comes in huge blocks of cheese or pre-packaged slices. Monterey is made from pasteurized cow’s milk and has a mellow taste comparable to Muenster.

It may be used to create grilled sandwiches, quesadillas, or just eaten with crackers. One of its finest characteristics is that it melts flawlessly, making it an excellent alternative for Muenster cheese. It’s also a great option for many baked meals and snacks.

See also  15 Best Beef Consomme Substitute That No One Talks About

Monterey To attain a semi-soft consistency, Jack cheese should be aged for two to one month. It should be matured for at least six months, preferably nine months, for the dry form. This results in a deeper, fuller taste as well as a tougher consistency.

Port Salut

Port Salut cheese is one of the oldest forms of cheese, going back to the mid-1800s. Monks at Notre Dame’s monastery in Port-du-Salut invented it.

This French cheese is made from partly skimmed pasteurized cow’s milk. It has a semi-soft texture and a savory but somewhat sweet taste.

Its propensity to melt readily is one of the reasons it is such a suitable alternative for Muenster cheese. It’s ideal for making Mornay sauce, which is the French version of bechamel sauce.

Port Salut also goes well with fondues and grilled cheese sandwiches. You may also cut it into slices, shred it, or cube it to serve with crackers or fruits. Furthermore, this creamy, buttery cheese will provide the finishing touch to your baked goods. Simply melt and sprinkle over any vegetables, pasta, or meat meal, and you’re done!

Out of the six kinds on our list, Port Salut has one of the lowest maturing durations. It is usually left for three to six weeks.


Provolone cheese is distinguished by its light yellow hue and strong, distinctive taste. It has a smooth, semi-firm consistency that readily grates and melts.

This cheese, made from whole cow’s milk, originates in southern Italy. It is now mostly produced in the Po Valley area of northern Italy.

This unusual cheese is often used in salad dressing. It also complements practically all baked foods, soups, and sandwiches. However, it is well known for its delectable tastes. It works well in pasta recipes like filled manicotti shells, ziti, and many more.

Typically, mild provolone cheese is matured for two to three months. Then there’s the darker Provolone, which is aged between six months and two years. The extended aging process imparts a spicier, deeper taste.

[Related Article: Can You Substitute Ricotta Cheese for Sour Cream?]

See also  How To Defrost Chicken In Microwave(Plus 3 Other Hacks)

The Takeaway

What is a decent Muenster cheese substitute? Any of the six varieties of cheese we discussed would be ideal. They’re all noted for their mildness, silky texture, and distinct nutty taste.

Best of all, they melt nicely, enabling you to incorporate them into practically any cuisine. They’re also great for appetizers, sandwiches, and cheese platters. The possibilities are endless: diced, sliced, grated, cubed, or melted!

Take a stroll around your local supermarkets and markets to check which of these cheeses are in stock. Then choose one and get started. These six are never going to let you down. You’ll always have a perfectly amazing supper (or fun snack) to enjoy, whether eaten cold or heated!


What cheese is a good substitute for Muenster cheese?

Provolone is a great substitution for Muenster cheese in almost any baked dish, as well as soups and sandwiches. Because provolone is semi-firm, it may be readily shredded and used as a salad dressing or as a component in pasta recipes and fillings.

Does Muenster cheese melt easily?

Because it melts nicely, it’s often used in grilled cheese sandwiches, tuna melts, quesadillas, cheeseburgers, macaroni and cheese, and pizza. Because the tastes compliment one other nicely, Muenster cheese is often served with beer.

Are Gouda and Muenster cheese the same?

The waxed rind of Gouda cheese is yellow, orange, or red on young cheeses and black on aged cheeses. Munster is a soft, cow’s milk cheese. The texture is similar to brie, but the washed rind procedure used to make the cheese gives it a sour taste.

What is a less expensive substitute for Gruyere cheese?

Swiss American Cheese

This cheese is likely to be available at any supermarket shop. It’s prepared in the Swiss tradition and looks a lot like Emmental cheese. When you want a less expensive alternative to Gruyère, use it instead.

What is the soft cheese that looks like Munster?

With its orange rind, Port Salut resembles Muenster. It costs more than some of the other options on this list. Swiss cheese is not as mild as Muenster, but if you must substitute it, go for the gentler Baby Swiss (Guggisberg produces the finest).

What is special about Muenster cheese?

With age, the buttery taste becomes more nuanced. While muenster cheese melts beautifully, it can also be readily sliced or shredded, making it a very versatile table cheese.The American muenster cheese has a creamy white hue, an orange peel, and a mild, somewhat nutty flavor.

What is the best cheese that melts?

Here’s our top ten list of the greatest melting cheeses, as well as the dishes we love to use them in.
Colby. Colby is a solid, mild-flavored, and creamy all-American cheese.
Monterey Jack.
Gouda that has been smoked.

Which cheese melts easily?

Cheddar. Shredded cheddar is ready to meet all of your cheesy dairy requirements. Shredded cheddar melts very nicely, whether topping chorizo stew or preparing a typical grilled cheese. It also adds a little crisp quality to the mix, which keeps things interesting.

What is the stretchiest cheese when melted?

Gouda is one among our stretchiest, meltiest local favorites.

Is Muenster cheese similar to Monterey Jack?

cheese from Muenster

It tastes quite similar to Monterey Jack. As a result, it’s a fantastic replacement. Use it in a great sandwich recipe that asks for semi-soft cheese slices.

Rate this post