15 Insane Balsamic Vinegar Substitutes for Healthy Baking

Balsamic vinegar originates in Italy, notably in the city of Modena. It has existed for a thousand years. It is a white grape vinegar that has been aged. Making it now is not much different, save for the use of more contemporary tools.

Balsamic vinegar has several health advantages, which is why it is popular as a baking ingredient among health-conscious people. In a nutshell, here are some options to consider when replacing it in your recipe.

  1. Red wine vinegar and sugar
  2. White wine vinegar and maple syrup
  3. Apple cider vinegar and sugar
  4. Special Soy Sauce Mix
  5. Vinaigrette
  6. Soy Sauce, lemon juice, and molasses
  7. White vinegar

If you can’t find anything acceptable from the list above, see our entire list of Balsamic Vinegar Substitutes below.

First, let’s look at how this item is manufactured, how it tastes, and why it’s regarded highly nutritious.

15 Best Substitute For Balsamic Vinegar 

It all begins with unfermented grapes. Their juice is carefully cooked until the texture thickens. The finished syrup is stored in barrels.

This technique pauses fermentation so that the acetic bacteria may do their job and produce balsamic vinegar.

It has acidity, as one would anticipate from vinegar. This variety also has sweet overtones and the perfume of the oak barrel in which it is preserved. If you obtain a lighter flavor version, you most certainly got a cheaper one.

However, for a variety of reasons, you may need to employ a replacement. The following alternatives should be able to replicate the flavor and benefits as closely as feasible.

Red Wine Vinegar And Sugar


The traditional substitute is balsamic vinegar for red wine vinegar. Some people even mix together the two kinds of vinegar. As a result, red wine vinegar and sugar make sense as a replacement for balsamic vinegar.

There are, nevertheless, distinctions, one of which is that red wine vinegar is less sweet. To make the substitute work, add a little sugar to it. Red wine vinegar is more acidic as well.

Adding some brown sugar should make red wine vinegar one of the finest substitutes, despite the tiny difference.

For every tablespoon of balsamic vinegar, combine half a tablespoon of brown sugar and one tablespoon of red wine vinegar. Brown sugar is the preferable alternative because it lends an oak tone, which mimics the woodsy, aged-in-a-barrel flavor of balsamic vinegar.

White Wine Vinegar And Maple Syrup


The white wine vinegar and maple syrup combination is a version of the white wine vinegar and sugar mixture. The texture of the syrup will make things simpler for you.

You don’t have to bother about cooking sugar to get a certain consistency. Instead, you only need to consider the appropriate ratios.

Maple syrup is another healthful choice. Having it in the kitchen means you may use it instead of honey.

Apple Cider Vinegar And Sugar


If you choose with this option, consider apple cider vinegar with sediment. Then combine it with sugar.

For each tablespoon of balsamic vinegar required, combine half a tablespoon of brown sugar with one tablespoon of apple cider vinegar. Combine these two ingredients before adding the remainder of your baking ingredients.

See also  18 Best Coconut Vinegar Substitute For Baking Like A Boss

This manner, you can confirm that the taste of the balsamic vinegar has been produced before combining it with other components.

Special Soy Sauce Mix

The particular soy sauce mixture is often used for cooking meat, but it may also be utilized in baking. The recipe takes advantage of readily available ingredients, particularly soy sauce.

When you have a little left over and need to extend the portion, you may combine it with balsamic vinegar.

One tablespoon of red wine vinegar, one teaspoon of grape jelly, and a half teaspoon of soy sauce may be substituted for one and a half tablespoons of balsamic vinegar.

This particular recipe, like the apple cider vinegar and sugar combination, is best mixed before adding the result to other components. To get the best results, combine everything in a jar and carefully mix it.



You might substitute vinaigrette for the balsamic vinegar. It’s one of those recipes that can be turned around. After all, you may make balsamic vinaigrette by combining balsamic vinegar and olive oil. You may try it the opposite way around.

The 1:1 ratio also makes incorporating the replacement into your recipe simpler.

Soy Sauce, Lemon juice And Molasses

Soy sauce appears once again in this other combo. As you look for other replacements with comparable taste characteristics to this one.

The obvious flavor difference between balsamic vinegar and soy sauce may put you off, but it must be combined with lemon juice and molasses. The combination produces a comparable taste and texture.

To experience the resultant blend more fully, combine the first three components before adding the rest. Lemon juice provides the acidity required to replicate balsamic vinegar.

White Vinegar


White vinegar is probably rather frequent in your home. It’s doubtful you won’t have it. It is available in larger bottles and does not need to be used in significant quantities. This component is also useful for cleaning.

You must combine five parts white vinegar and one part sugar. To get the desired consistency, cook the mixture over low heat. Stir the mixture to ensure that all of the sugar crystals have dissolved.

Lemon/Citrus Juices

Some individuals even drink lemon or citrus juice by themselves. These juices provide the acid that balsamic vinegar requires. It cannot, however, supply you with the sweet, woodsy taste you are used to.

However, these juices may give the necessary freshness for your cuisine. You might certainly try with a little brown sugar.

Fruity Vinegar And Sugar


Other fruity vinegars, such as raspberry vinegar, may be used in place of apple cider vinegar.

One tablespoon of fruity vinegar may be combined with half a teaspoon of brown sugar. You may be able to imitate the flavor of balsamic vinegar with this sweet and sour mix.

Malt Vinegar


If you want sweet and sour in one, malt vinegar is a good option. Instead of oak, you’ll get barley or a flavor similar to beer with malt vinegar.

This alternative will also have a stronger flavor than other replacement substances.

See also  12 Recommended Ghee Substitute For Baking Or Frying

You may, however, mask the flavor with sugar. Ensure that the crystals are entirely dissolved and that the consistency is similar to that of balsamic vinegar.

Sherry Vinegar 

Sherry vinegar is the Spanish relative of balsamic vinegar. They are less sweet and have a gentler flavor than balsamic vinegar.

Sherry vinegar may be used in place of balsamic vinegar in sauces, stews, salads, and marinades.

If you have it on hand, you may substitute it for balsamic vinegar in a 1:1 ratio. You don’t need to add anything more to this one to make it taste better!

Chinese Black Vinegar


Chinese black vinegar is a common component in Chinese cooking and may be used in place of balsamic vinegar.

This vinegar, made from glutinous rice and malt, has a flavor similar to balsamic vinegar but is less sweet.

If your recipe calls for the sweetness of balsamic vinegar, you may need to substitute 1 tablespoon with 2 teaspoons of black vinegar.

Elderberry Balsamic Vinegar

Elderberry Balsamic Vinegar Vinegar is an elderberry syrup-based balsamic vinegar. They are extremely beneficial when used in place of ordinary balsamic vinegar in dressings or marinades.

Tart, rich, and sweet, many bakers prefer to use them in their recipes to add zesty hints of juicy purple elderberry.

If you have it on hand, you may substitute it for balsamic vinegar in a 1:1 ratio.

Golden Balsamic Vinegar


One of the closest replacements for balsamic vinegar is golden balsamic. It’s created in the form of classic balsamic vinegar, but using light-colored grapes instead of dark ones.

They have the same pleasantly nuanced taste as ordinary balsamic vinegar, but with a crisper finish for your baking recipe. They are readily interchangeable and may be used interchangeably in any recipe.

Champagne Vinegar


Champagne vinegar should only be considered as a replacement if you do not want a strong taste in your baked items, depending on the texture and flavor desired.

They are ideal for adding a dash of acidity and wonderful flavor to baked goods.

It has a light, mild, sweet, and tangy taste and is fermented from Champagne. It may serve as a balsamic substitute, particularly if you add some soy sauce and molasses to it for a richer flavor. However, this combination is not required.

Balsamic Vinegar Substitute Related FAQs 

What are the reasons you need balsamic vinegar substitutes?

You ran out of balsamic vinegar

The most apparent reason for needing a replacement is that you have run out of balsamic vinegar. This vinegar is often sold in tiny bottles. Of course, you don’t have to use much of it. However, since it has specialized applications, it is easy to lose track of how much you have left.

Don’t be concerned. You can locate additional ingredients to allow you to complete that baking project you planned to perform with numerous potential substitutions.

You want to explore other flavor profiles

When you add balsamic vinegar to your baking recipes, you’ll get the woodsy, sweet, and acidic flavor you’ve been looking for. You may want something less sweet or something sweeter. Red wine vinegar, for example, might give a less sugary alternative.

Experiment with different components to obtain the exact taste you desire. You may be surprised by the mixtures that appeal to your taste buds the most.

See also  12 Best Substitute For Orange Zest In Baking You Can Use Now

You have more of the other vinegar varieties

You may also want to know whether you can get away with utilizing more of the vinegar kinds that you currently have on hand. You may then keep the balsamic vinegar for additional uses, such as special events.

It would help if you had a less expensive option

Balsamic vinegar is more expensive than other varieties of vinegar. The most costly vinegar, in reality, is a form of aged balsamic vinegar. Of course, you can get some cheaper knockoffs.

However, there is no need to do so since you already have alternatives in your kitchen. Make the most of what you have.

How do you save money on balsamic vinegar?

If the only difficulty you have with balsamic vinegar is the price, you should retain it as a baking component.

Surprisingly, the finest balsamic vinegar costs around the same as a nice bottle of wine. The price of aged balsamic vinegar is high.

Traditional balsamic vinegar must be at least 12 years old and costs about $100 for a 100 ml bottle. Any variety that has been aged for more than 12 years and sells for a lower price is most likely not real.

To save money, consider balsamic vinegar that has been aged between 3 and 7 years. It will lack the taste subtleties of the matured version. However, it is still superior to any other alternative.

Should Balsamic Vinegar Be Refrigerated After Opening?

After opening, balsamic vinegar does not need to be refrigerated.

After opening and using the balsamic vinegar for the first time, carefully shut it and store it at room temperature to preserve the taste character.

5 Balsamic Vinegar Benefits

Balsamic vinegar has several health advantages.

Here are some of them:

  • Suitable for diabetic people.
  • Improves your overall digestive system.
  • It helps to lower cholesterol.
  • Regulate blood pressure
  • Excellent on the skin

Can You Make Balsamic Vinegar At Home?

You certainly can. Even while there are several viable options to consider, you may also explore manufacturing your own balsamic vinegar at home.

  1. Pick a red wine with less than 12% alcohol
  2. Distilled water in the amount of a full wine bottle
  3. Connect the mother of vinegar to a spigot-equipped crock.
  4. Pour your diluted wine into the crock
  5. Cover the wine with three layers of cheesecloth
  6. Secure the cover with a rubber band
  7. Place the crock in a dark place at 60 to 80 degrees Fahrenheit for three months, or until you can smell it.
  8. Use a sieve to strain the vinegar
  9. Remove the remainder, such as the mother of vinegar.
  10. Strain it again just to be sure
  11. In a saucepan, combine the vinegar and 2 cups of sugar.
  12. Simmer it in medium heat
  13. You may preserve it in a glass jar with three layers of cheesecloth over it for another two months.

Do you notice how much work goes into making balsamic vinegar? If you’re in a hurry, simply use the substitutions on the list above. It will be faster. On the other hand, you may make your own aged vinegar on the side.


What is a healthy substitute for balsamic vinegar?

Substitute 1 tbsp. cider vinegar or red wine vinegar + 12 tsp. sugar for 1 tbsp. balsamic vinegar.

What is a good substitute for balsamic vinegar in cooking?

+ maple syrup or honey + red wine vinegar

What is the finest balsamic vinegar substitute? Here’s how to produce a balsamic substitute: Combine 1 tablespoon red wine vinegar and 2 tablespoons maple syrup in a small mixing bowl. Adding sweetness to red wine vinegar mimics the depth and roundness of taste seen in balsamic vinegar.

What is the healthiest vinegar?

Vinegar of Modena

This is one of the healthiest and most nutritional vinegar kinds. Furthermore, the antioxidants in this vinegar are believed to reduce the risk of heart disease and cancer.

Can I use Worcestershire sauce instead of balsamic vinegar?

Worcestershire sauce is another popular product that may be used as a one-to-one substitute for balsamic vinegar in tiny quantities.

Is balsamic vinegar as healthy as apple cider vinegar?

Balsamic vinegar contains 18mg of potassium per tablespoon, but apple cider has just 11mg. The antioxidants in balsamic vinegar also help decrease LDL cholesterol, while apple cider works similarly to lower blood lipid levels. Both vinegars have been shown in trials to help with weight reduction and blood sugar management.

Is balsamic vinegar a healthy option?

Balsamic vinegar is a great alternative for those who want to maintain or reduce their cholesterol levels. Balsamic vinegar’s antioxidants target the “scavenger cells” that are hazardous to your body and raise your LDL (bad cholesterol) levels.

Can I substitute lemon juice for balsamic vinegar?

Lemon juice and lime juice plus sugar. In a pinch, a simple sweet and acidic mixture may be used to simulate the fundamental ingredients of balsamic vinegar. This will not work well for a sophisticated glaze, but it will enough for a basic dressing or marinade. Simply combine equal parts lemon and lime juice with sugar and taste.

Can you replace balsamic vinegar with rice vinegar?

Substitute for Balsamic Vinegar

1 tablespoon balsamic vinegar may be replaced with 1 tablespoon brown rice vinegar or Chinese black vinegar. You may also replace balsamic vinegar with apple cider or red wine vinegar and either sugar or honey.

Is there a difference between vinegar and balsamic vinegar?

Vinegar of Balsamic Origin

Balsamic vinegar, unlike most other vinegars, is not made from fermented alcohol. It is prepared by aging crushed grape juice in oak barrels, which causes it to thicken and concentrate over time.

What vinegar is best for heart health?

These animal studies demonstrate that apple cider vinegar may reduce cholesterol and triglyceride levels, as well as numerous other risk factors for heart disease. Vinegar has also been found in animal experiments to lower blood pressure, which is a key risk factor for heart disease and renal disorders.

Rate this post