14 Best Tomato Juice Substitutes You Should Know Today

You think tomato juice when I say tomato. Yes, tomato juice is one of the most common applications for tomatoes. Some people consider it a daily health drink, while others can’t make a Bloody Mary without it.

Tomato juice may also be utilized in dishes that call for the sweet, earthy taste of tomatoes. It’s flexible and delicious, and you’d be silly to run out of it.

Tomato juice is also heavy in salt, which is why it is drinkable (and refreshing) on its own. Some individuals may desire to reduce their salt consumption, while others may be allergic to tomatoes. If that’s the case, here are some tomato juice substitutes:

  1. Tomato sauce
  2. Tomato paste
  3. Whole or diced canned tomatoes
  4. Tomato soup
  5. Catsup(Ketchup)
  6. Marinara sauce
  7. Tomato passata(Tomato Puree)
  8. Vegetable broth
  9. Juice other vegetables

Tomato juice is both tasty and nutritious. If you like tomatoes, stocking up on juice is usually a good idea. In case you run out, here are 14 tomato juice replacements you may try:

 14 Best Tomato Juice Substitute

Tomato Sauce


Tomato sauce is the most prevalent tomato product, thus something is wrong if your pantry or nearby grocery store does not carry it. Depending on your recipe, there are several tomato sauce brands (and tastes) to pick from.

The first thing to note is that tomato sauce has a thicker texture. If you’re substituting tomato sauce for tomato juice, dilute the consistency with water. The proportions are simple: mix equal parts tomato sauce and water.

Because tomato sauce is made from whole tomatoes, the tomato content is an estimate. You might choose a tomato sauce that isn’t too spiced or seasoned in terms of taste. Spaghetti sauce is already made with spices, garlic, and a beautiful Italian taste.

Choose a tomato sauce with a high percentage of tomato and little seasonings. This allows you to add any components you need for your unique recipe that calls for tomato juice.

Tomato Paste

Tomato paste is the next best substitute for tomato juice. Tomato paste, like tomato sauce, has a thicker texture, therefore diluting it down will suffice. Use 1 part tomato paste and 4 parts water to produce a runny tomato juice substitute.

Most tomato paste products have a taste and consistency comparable to tomato juice. After all, tomato paste is one of the primary components stated for tomato juice. Don’t be startled if you discover that tomato juice contains reconstituted tomato paste. They are more similar than they look.

See also  Swiss Cheese Vs Gruyere Cheese: Who Is The Winner?

Check the ingredient list of the tomato paste for any residues of additional spices or tastes.

Whole or Diced Canned Tomatoes


If you can’t locate a replacement for liquefied tomato juice, whole or diced canned tomatoes are a safe choice. The tomatoes include tomato juice and citric acid, so they are not completely flavorless.

Because these canned tomatoes come with their skins and seeds, you’ll need a food processor to soften them up. The mixture will then be drained to eliminate any seeds or solid pieces, and the leftover liquid will be the tomato juice substitute. You may now enjoy your Bloody Mary with your own personal mix.

What if you don’t have a food processor? Manually crush or pound the tomatoes before straining.

Tomato Soup

When compared to other tomato juice alternatives, the texture of tomato soup is more accurate. its primary distinction is its function. Tomato juice is now ready for consumption. Tomato soup is often served hot and serves as a meal on its own. It is frequently sweeter and tangier to complement croutons or dinner rolls.

That rich taste will need to be balanced with 1 part soup and 3 parts water. Because certain soup brands have a milder taste, the ratio may be lowered to 1 part soup and 2 parts water at your option. Your sweetness tolerance may influence the ratio.

If you still find tomato soup to be too sweet for your recipe, there are other options.



If you like fries and hotdogs, you should have catsup (or ketchup) on hand. You’re in luck since that’s another tomato juice substitute.

Catsup is a viscous liquid that is often sold in a glass or squeeze container. To dilute that thick condiment to tomato juice proportions, use 1 part catsup and 8 parts water. Because it includes sugars and spices, catsup has a completely distinct taste profile than tomato juice.

It has a strong tangy flavor that we like as a condiment. It may taste different as a tomato juice alternative. You may either modify your recipe to accommodate for the flavors in your catsup or go for the catsup with the smallest ingredient list.

Marinara Sauce

Marinara sauce is a tomato-based sauce that complements spaghetti and mozzarella sticks beautifully. Its delectable combination of spices and herbs makes it an easy choice for savory recipes. This sauce’s distinct flavor distinguishes it from standard tomato sauce.

If you want to use marinara sauce instead of tomato juice, bear in mind that it already contains notes of basil, oregano, and garlic. It’s a ready-to-eat flavor that requires little or no elaboration.

See also  13 Best Boursin Cheese Substitute You Never Knew Exist

If the marinara sauce has the same consistency as tomato sauce, use the same proportion of 1 part marinara sauce to 1 part water.

Tomato Passata(Tomato Puree)


Tomato puree is another name for tomato passata. Because it is 100% tomato and free of chemicals and spices, tomato passata is arguably the purest form of produced tomatoes available.

Tomato passata, as opposed to crushed tomatoes, is smooth and thick. The consistency is comparable to tomato sauce, but without the seasonings. It is a good alternative for tomato juice since it retains the natural tomato taste.

Vegetable Broth

If it’s the savory taste you’re looking rather than the tomato component, you may use veggie broth for the tomato juice. The texture is already perfect, so all you have to do now is alter the taste to obtain that tomato-ey finish.

You may duplicate the sweet and sour flavor by adding sugar, vinegar, or lemon juice. Adjust your condiments proportionately to avoid over-seasoning the soup. If the color is still wrong, try adding a few drops of red food coloring.

Vegetable broth would be an excellent substitution for savory recipes, soups, and sauces that do not call for tomatoes. This is not an option for your Bloody Mary.

Fresh tomatoes

Fresh tomatoes are a natural, healthful, and unprocessed substitute for tomato juice. This garden-fresh variation takes a little more effort, but the end product is a very customized juice that you can season or flavor whatever you choose.

You must remove the seeds (and skin) before juicing or mixing. You’ll need to add water to thin down the texture. The essential ingredients required to enhance the tomato taste of your freshly prepared juice are salt and sugar. concoction or combine them all to get that delectably raw concoction.

Juice Other Vegetables

If you already have a regular juice regimen that includes lycopene-rich tomato juice, you may juice or mix additional fruits and vegetables to get your sweet fix.

Other reddish-colored veggies, such as beets and carrots, are high in minerals, fiber, and Vitamin C and would be an acceptable substitute. Lycopene is also found in red peppers, and oranges lend a citrus flavor.

Juicing allows you to combine different veggies to acquire the same nutritious value as tomato juice. Lemon may also be used to lend a subtle hint of sourness.

See also  13 Best Beef Shank Substitute For Human Carnivores

Roasted Red Peppers

You read it correctly.Roasted red peppers and tomato juice have a lot in common, and it’s not just the color red. Roasted red peppers have a unique taste and slight spiciness, as well as an enticing scent.

The goal is to mix the peppers until they have a texture similar to tomato juice. Adding water will assist to thin the mixture. If you’re looking for a new tomato experience, consider roasted red peppers. Their taste is distinctively spicy and toasty.


Tamarind may seem to be a weird tomato substitute, particularly given its appearance, but don’t judge a book by its cover. Tamarind has the same sweet tart taste as tomato juice, so it takes care of the flavor issue. Tamarind, if any, has such a deep taste that it may lend a distinct touch to foods.

The hue may change somewhat, so keep that in mind if you want your dishes to be bright red. Soaking the tamarind in water will result in a runnier texture that is comparable to tomato juice. Use tamarind to elevate your culinary masterpieces with the same consistency and powerful taste.

Beet juice

Because they have a comparable consistency and nutritional advantages, beet juice and tomato juice may be used interchangeably. If you’ve ever had beets, you know they have a rich, earthy flavor. That is precisely how the juice tastes. It also has a deep purple hue, akin to plumsquite, as opposed to the brilliant red of tomatoes.

The taste may be off, but adding lemon can help you get a more tomato-like flavor. Use beet juice instead of tomato juice for a healthy, purple-colored alternative!

Make your own Tomato Juice


We’ll finish the list with a fantastic homemade alternative that matches the original taste and consistency of tomato juice. Making your own mixture allows you to customize the taste depending on your preferences and what you have on hand in the kitchen.

You may attempt this example recipe or conduct your own experiment. There is no incorrect recipe or combination here.

3 cup onions (chopped). Mix in a splash of spicy sauce, sugar, salt, and pepper. When the texture is delicate, you may combine or purée them together, or drain the juice.2 pounds of tomatoes, 1 cup celery, and 1 cup onion, simmered or boiled

Keep your combination in bottles in the fridge so you may have tomato juice on hand at all times. To add a distinctive touch, experiment with other components or fruits in the combination.


What can you substitute for the missing ingredient tomato juice?

To make 2 cups of tomato sauce, combine 4 cup tomato paste and 1 cup water.2 cups tomato sauce with 12 cup water equals 1 cup tomato juice. 3 tablespoons tomato sauceSubstitute 1 tomato juice

How to can tomato juice the old fashioned way?

There is a 2-inch headspace. Then wipe the rim clean with a clean towel. Then place the lid on top and tighten the band just until it is finger-tight.To each pint of sterilized canning jar, add 1 tablespoon of bottled lemon juice, or 2 teaspoons in quart jars. Fill jars halfway with heated tomato juice, leaving 1 inch at the top.

Can you sub tomato soup for tomato juice?

It’s also a good idea to swap tomato soup for juice. Without a doubt, the flavor and texture will alter in some manner; nonetheless, the basic taste of tomato will always be there. What exactly is this? However, you may easily add water to get a similar liquid feel to your juice.

Which tomato juice is the healthiest?

When looking for a healthy option, go for 100% tomato juice with no additional salt or sweeteners. Furthermore, persons with gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) should avoid tomato juice since it might aggravate symptoms (28).

What can I use in place of tomato juice?

2 cup water (4 oz.In a pinch, diluted catsup or ketchup may be used in place of tomato juice in a recipe. Combine one part ketchup and eight parts water. For example, 1 tablespoon ketchup (0.5 ounces) and 1 teaspoon mustard

Why is there a shortage of tomato juice in supermarkets?

Because of the decline in temperatures, tomatoes are taking longer to mature, resulting in less tomatoes available to harvest and export. Continued severe weather, particularly heavy rain, in February 2023 has caused more tomato export complications.

How to make tomato juice at home?

Chop your tomatoes and place them in a big saucepan over medium heat with a splash of water. Cook for 20-30 minutes. To soften the tomatoes, keep stirring constantly. To extract the juice, pass the softened tomatoes through a sieve or food mill, leaving the skin and seeds remain.

Why add lemon juice to canned tomatoes?

When processing whole, crushed, or juiced tomatoes in a boiling water bath, add lemon juice or citric acid to guarantee safe acidity.

Does adding lemon juice to canned tomatoes change the flavor?

Canning tomatoes using citric acid powder yielded excellent results with no conflicting tastes. Tomatoes canned with commercial cider vinegar and bottled lemon juice had changed tastes, as predicted.

What is a substitute for V8 juice?

In a large saucepan, combine 4 tablespoons sugar, horseradish, Worcestershire sauce, and black pepper. Bring to a boil and simmer for 20 minutes, or until flavors mix.Combine vegetable juices, water, lemon juice, and 1 1

Rate this post